Wikijunior talk:New Title Policy/Unstable

I think that this document badly needs to be updated and revised. So I'm being bold and doing so. --xixtas 05:54, 14 January 2007 (UTC)

Motion to adopt
If there are no objections I will make this policy active on the grounds that:
 * 1) It is a heckuva lot better than what is already there.
 * 2) No-one has spoken against it.
 * 3) Misunderstandings that this document address are damaging to Wikijunior and stifling its development.
 * 4) This document has been up for review for three weeks, and has been well publicized in the staff lounge and on various users talk pages.

-- xixtas 17:18, 5 February 2007 (UTC)


 * Keep in mind that I wrote the original "policy" in an attempt to change the eariler "policy" for Wikijunior: That no other books other than the "original three" Wikijunior books could be written.  I felt that a better solution could happen to allow some new Wikijunior books, but continue the original philosophy of generally slow growth and encouraging a "polishing" of Wikijunior books rather than a huge expansion of titles.  I'll leave the results of this effort to others to try and determine for themselves.
 * BTW, I am supportive of the current changes and would suggest that this be moved to become "official policy". --Rob Horning 14:12, 6 February 2007 (UTC)


 * I appreciate that the existing new title policy was an effective problem solving step that helped Wikijunior grow. I'm glad that you find the revised policy to be acceptable. --xixtas 16:34, 8 February 2007 (UTC)