Wikibooks:Requests for deletion/Yubnub

Yubnub
This appears to be a Wikipedia article moved to Wikibooks without cause. We do not seem to have a Yubnub book that this would be part off. I want to transwiki this back to Yubnub commands. For example, IRC commands is at Wikipedia. First I open this poll. --Kernigh 21:12, 2 April 2006 (UTC)


 * Comment - leaning to deletion - This doesn't seem like a Wikipedia article to me, and something likely to be deleted from Wikipedia in its current condition. Obviously there were a number of quality markup tags on Wikipedia as noted by this earlier edit.  It seems as though this is more of a beginnings of a language reference book, which seems to fit more with Wikibooks than Wikipedia.  Still, I'm not attached to it, and I would have to agree that I would like to have seen some discussion on Wikipedia first of some kind before this was removed.  I don't see any of that discussion at all, and your comment on Wikipedia seems to be the first comment that anybody made on the discussion page.  --Rob Horning 23:06, 2 April 2006 (UTC)
 * From what I know, transwikis do not require discussion. For example, transwikis from Wikibooks use, and discussion (through this VFD) page is optional. --Kernigh 15:32, 4 April 2006 (UTC)
 * While a full discussion may not be completely necessary, a rationale can and should be included somewhere for why you move or delete something. Leaving out the rationale anywhere on either a talk page or even in the transwiki comment is not a good idea.  Obvious transwikied content (aka it is not in English) is reasonable, or if it simply fits better in another project might be a good idea.  In this case, it was tagged by a Wikipedia admin for transwiki to Wikibooks, and he may have a point.  The real question that would have to be asked is if this content can be expanded into a more book-length multi-page work, or is it something that can be simply covered as a simple encyclopedia article?  If deletionists on Wikipedia want to remove content like this, I would support setting up a bookshelf on Wikibooks just for this sort of content.  --Rob Horning 15:52, 4 April 2006 (UTC)

Kept - no one voted to move this back to Wikipedia. --Kernigh 01:44, 23 April 2006 (UTC)