Wikibooks:Requests for deletion/RuneScape/Guides/Cheats

RuneScape/Guides/Cheats
This was nominated for speedy deletion by User:Richard x:


 *  . 

The user is referring to RuneScape/Guides/Anti-Scam and RuneScape/Guides/Anti-Hack. However, 68.163.136.216 decided to remove the tag, claiming that "I cannot see any reference to it on TBD, and therefore have removed the sign".

I mention that RuneScape/Guides/Cheats is a recent transwiki from Wikipedia. The page is now also on WB:VIP because of vandalism. It appears that Richard x's request for deletion, and 68.163.136.216's removal of that request, are both independent of any vandalism. I now open this poll. I would suggest keeping this page, unless the page is redundant with the anti-scam and anti-hack guides already here, in which case I would suggest deleting the page. --Kernigh 03:26, 27 March 2006 (UTC)


 * Merge and Delete - Most of the content on this page is found elsewhere within the Runescape guide. I came very close to deleting the page earlier, but I wanted to give the regular Runescape contributors a chance to look at it and pick through what they wanted to keep before I got rid of it.  I still think this should be the direction this content should go now.  --Rob Horning 15:21, 27 March 2006 (UTC)


 * Delete - This guide is useless. Almost all the information in the guide is covered in both RuneScape/Guides/Anti-Scam and RuneScape/Guides/Anti-Hack. The only part of the article that isn't in the two guides is the Bot/Auto/Macro/Scripting current issues, which I, from my POV, has nothing to do with RS. And what the heck is TBD? Richard 22:44, 27 March 2006 (UTC)


 * Delete - Having reviewed this, I now agree with Richard that this "Cheats" page is redundant, and we should delete it – no merge necessary. Remember, this page was moved from Wikipedia, not originally submitted to this Wikibook. I was not able to verify that scar, Aryan, Sbot, xScar exist as they are described here. The bot community is trying to make contractually illegal the informing of JAGex or the public about bots; maybe we should mention that somewhere in the book. --Kernigh 15:28, 4 April 2006 (UTC)

Deleted - This page has shown repeated vandalism, so much so that I "borrowed" the   template from Wikipedia and updated it for Wikibooks, and added it to this page, in addition to protecting the page from edits. This should be a temporary fix, and I don't mind having even this page content deleted, but this at least gives notice that it was voted out of existance. I guess Wikibooks is growing up and having to deal with this kind of garbage. This whole section can be archived in about a week. --Rob Horning 02:34, 14 April 2006 (UTC)