Wikibooks:Requests for deletion/Baxilic

Baxilic
Per the (two-page) wikibook, Baxilic is "a language based on the language in Orson Scott Card's Memory of Earth". It appears to be entirely fictional. Google comes up with only five pages, of which this wikibook is listed number one. This doesn't seem like something we should be covering, Jguk 08:14, 25 February 2006 (UTC)


 * Keep - Dispite rumors to the contrary, I am generally an inclusionist, especially if I can't find a specific policy that the content violates. The content here is just enough, for me, that it goes beyond the eternal stub, and there is some real, actual content on the subject.  It barely crosses that line for me, however.  The only issue that I see which needs to be resolved is if most of what is here is a copyright violation (copied from a fan site or from notes by Orson Scott Card).  While there may be some controversy over the creation of full Wikimedia sister projects in languages like this, I fail to see how that standard needs to be applied to content like this here in Wikibooks. --Rob Horning 13:42, 25 February 2006 (UTC)


 * Delete We have other made-up languages at Wikibooks, but only Quenya is a language book we have introduced as part of fiction.  Perhaps Klingon or Middle Earth languages (such as Quenya) are or would be of enough interest to be worth keeping.  But that lack of Google links and Wikipedia entry would suggest that there is no similar interest in Baxilic.  I am somewhat uncomfortable voting to delete without leaving notes on the authors' pages so they could contradict me.  However all of the authors are IP addresses.  (To be clear, I don't see their being IP addresses as reason to delete the book; I just wish they weren't IP address so we could let them know of this vote.)  --JMRyan 22:33, 10 March 2006 (UTC)


 * Delete To me, this language "Baxilic" does not exist, so we cannot write a book about it. My search yielded 18 results, all connected to Wikibooks! --Kernigh 00:32, 3 April 2006 (UTC)