User talk:Windrider46

While I appreciate your work on the Muggles' Guide, I have to point out that even in the books there are contradictions (Marcus Flint, whether prefects can dock points), and that several times Rowling has made comments in interviews that are directly contradicted by things in the books. The books are a cohesive and integrated look into that universe, and Rowling has gone to considerable effort to make them that way; she won't have the time for research into back story in a live interview that will allow her to keep that cohesiveness. Live interviews and other off-the-cuff remarks have to be discounted for that reason. The same does not apply to Pottermore, which is actually researched before the information in it goes live; but the information there does not necessarily add to our understanding. Chazz (talk) 15:49, 30 March 2016 (UTC)