User talk:67.182.157.63

Welcome to Wikibooks.

Please sign up for a free account so that we can still reach you when your IP address changes.

Also, please note that we are writing textbooks on this site; as such, your repeated answering of the study questions in the Muggles' Guide is counter-productive. Study questions are there for the eventual users of these texts, specifically to aid their understanding of the text. Additionally, we are making an effort to not put spoilers in the text, so as to allow someone who is reading the text for the first time to be able to use the Guide in parallel with his reading.

Contributions are always welcomed, but we would prefer that they enhance the text's usability, rather than hinder it. Chazz (talk) 21:00, 8 March 2009 (UTC)

Changes to Muggles' Guide / Order of the Phoenix / Chapter 38
I have to say, once more, that it would be a lot easier to discuss changes with you if you had an actual user name, as IP addresses are likely to change and I have no idea if I'm talking to the same editor as the one who actually made the changes in question. Additionally, with only an IP you won't reliably get notices of changes on your talk page. Finally, it seems you only visit very occasionally, once a month or so based on your edit log, which makes it very difficult to continue a conversation.

Your comment on your change to OotP:38, that it is not wishful thinking, is basically what the text said that you removed. "While this may seem like wishful thinking..." with the implication that it is not, in fact, anything of the sort. I have tentatively accepted the changes, but feel that they weaken the feel overall and am not ruling out reverting them at a later date. Chazz (talk) 15:30, 1 April 2011 (UTC)