Talk:Wing Chun Forms/Siu Nim Tau

If I might be so bold, might I suggest this page would function much better with images. I am not sure if that's in the style of Wikibooks.

The page is excellent as a quick reminder of what order everything falls out in (particularly that Wu/Tan/Bong/Gahn bit) but if you don't already know what the e.g. Huen sau is, this page will be completely opaque. Perhaps the hand positions etc could be linked to pages describing how they are performed.

I hope you don't mind this mild nitpicking. Thank you for recording the form online. - 124.168.52.162 (talk) 13:27, 28 March 2009 (UTC)

It's a fine suggestion. In theory I'm working on both an illustrated version of the Wing Chun Forms book, to be released as PDF with embedded photos, and a Wing Chun Movements book, describing how to do the named movements, also with photos. In practice, I'm up to my ears in family and work. Expected release date 2020&hellip; SteveF (talk) 03:46, 8 July 2009 (UTC)

I agree entirely that this page needs imagery; without it, the article is hardly more than a jumble of words! If the author, SteveF is not up to adding the imagery for the reasons given, then someone else should be given permission to do so, or to post his/ her own (new) article, with extensive imagery (i.e., taking nothing for granted, or assuming that the reader is a greenhorn). I was going to post a comment suggesting that imagery was sorely needed here when I clicked on the Discussion tab and saw that someone else had already done so, i.e., had had the same immediate gut response to the article as had I, a greenhorn, by the way.Wikiaide (discuss • contribs) 06:22, 31 August 2011 (UTC)