Talk:Public International Law/Interaction/International Law and Domestic Law

Review, May 21, 2023
Congratulations on this great chapter, dear Raffaela! I agree with Max's assessment and have added a few more comments in the text. Overall, I think some more non-European examples would be nice. Regarding required knowledge: you could maybe link to the nineteenth century chapter and/or the general introduction to the history part (both almost finished offline) and to a (also still missing) introduction to the 'interaction' part. Herzlich

Sué

Sué González Hauck (discuss • contribs) 12:12, 21 May 2023 (UTC)

Review: May 19, 2023
Your chapter begins with a well-crafted introduction that highlights the core questions surrounding this interaction and effectively sets the stage. One of the strengths of your chapter lies in its ability to situate the problems within their relevant context. You skillfully present the challenges that arise when international law and domestic law intersect, taking into account the differing legal systems, sources of law, and mechanisms of enforcement. This contextualization not only enhances the students' understanding but also allows for a deeper exploration of the intricacies involved in the interaction between international and domestic legal frameworks.

Your emphasis on courts and their role in this interaction is a commendable approach. By focusing on the role of courts, you underscore their significance as key actors in resolving conflicts between international and domestic legal norms. This emphasis provides students with a valuable perspective on the practical implications of the interaction between these legal spheres.

You will find some comments in your chapter in which I elaborate on something more specifically.

Some minor things:


 * Some parts of the chapter are still missing.
 * There are some issues with the formatting of the footnotes, which are not always consistent with the OSCOLA citation style. To ensure the chapter is fully compliant with OSCOLA, you should review the formatting of the footnotes and make necessary corrections.
 * Note also that the following parts are still missing: required knowledge, learning objectives, further readings, conclusion
 * You could add some links to other chapters of the textbook.
 * Note that I have made some linguistic improvements to the text

--Max Milas (discuss • contribs) 16:50, 19 May 2023 (UTC)

Review: Deepa
Dear Raffaela

Thank you for sharing the outline of your chapter. I am particularly looking forward to the discussions on "Transformation Legislation", "Backlash", and "Domestic Law in International Courts".

Under section B, it would be great to see a sub-heading on the role of national institutions (parliament/ courts, etc.). On the role of the courts, in particular, a specific section on transformative judicial interpretations would also be interesting.

Thanks once again for sharing your work.

Best wishes Deepa Kansra