Talk:Muggles' Guide to Harry Potter/Characters/Regulus Black

Not Very Unique
I'm just getting familiar with Wikibooks, and I know the Harry Potter guide is under complete construction, but as it appears the Regulus page is definitely not in the style that it should be, and it looks copy and pasted word-for-word from the Harry Potter Lexicon. If you want the Muggles' Guide to be unique, you might as well make the pages distinct from the Lexicon; otherwise, it's just a Wiki version of the Lex. No offense intended, I hope none was taken. Fbv65edel 21:24, 21 February 2006 (UTC)

Occlumency? Not suggested
Regulus must have been relatively skilled in Occlumency to have blocked Voldemort from reading his thoughts regarding the Dark Lord's evil plans. There's nothing that would suggest this. By all suggestions, use of Legilimency requires making an effort to read the thoughts in question. Regulus did not need to use Occlumency when he volunteered Kreacher, as he was then a devoted Death Eater. After Kreacher came back, Regulus was shocked by what Voldemort had done to him - it is suggested everywhere that it was this that turned Regulus over, and there was not any previous conscious espionage. But then he did not need to use Occlumency either, because he did not meet Voldemort at the time, nor did the latter have any grounds for suspicion so that he would make inquiries (even if a skilled wizard can perhaps do these from somewhat afar). As it were, probably made extra sure he would not meet him, and set out to the Cave only a short time afterwards.--131.159.76.230 (discuss) 14:56, 29 March 2017 (UTC)