Talk:Foundations and Assessment of Education/Edition 1/Foundations Table of Contents/Chapter 6/Experts Take Sides/Peer Review One

PEER REVIEW FEEDBACK
 * Use this template to grade the peer reviews you receive.

Directions

-
 * Use this rubric to evaluate EACH peer review you receive for your article.
 * You will award points for each of the sections in this rubric.
 * Write the scores below in the section called "Scores".
 * Your evaluation will determine your reviewer's grade for this assignment; please take your time and grade honestly and fairly.

SCORES

 * Includes all components:                _30______ / 30


 * Reflects Standards or Criteria:         ___5____ / 5


 * Understandable:                         __5_____ / 5


 * Specific:                               ___5____  / 5


 * Achievable:                             __5_____  / 5

TOTAL SCORE:                              __50_____  /50

Comments (1 + 1)
Provide ONE compliment and ONE suggestion for your peer reviewer. For example, what did you find most or least effective? What would make the feedback more effective?

The author of my peer review was effective about choosing which section of the paper to edit.....Instead of copying the whole paper and editing the whole paper, the reviewer chose a paragraph that was viewed as being most in need of revisions. The reviewer then added some helpful reviews to this paragraph....

Suggestion: the reviewer could have given some additional comments on mechanics and grammar rather than just giving edits of a pasted paragraph.

Mbrowder (talk) 19:52, 22 July 2009 (UTC)