Talk:Foundations and Assessment of Education/Edition 1/Foundations Table of Contents/Chapter 4/In the News/Peer Review One

PEER REVIEW FEEDBACK
 * Use this template to grade the peer reviews you receive.

Directions

-
 * Use this rubric to evaluate EACH peer review you receive for your article.
 * You will award points for each of the sections in this rubric.
 * Write the scores below in the section called "Scores".
 * Your evaluation will determine your reviewer's grade for this assignment; please take your time and grade honestly and fairly.

SCORES

 * Includes all components:                __30_____ / 30


 * Reflects Standards or Criteria:         ___5____ / 5


 * Understandable:                         ___5____ / 5


 * Specific:                               ___5____  / 5


 * Achievable:                             ____4___  / 5

TOTAL SCORE:                              ___49____  /50

Comments (1 + 1)
Provide ONE compliment and ONE suggestion for your peer reviewer. For example, what did you find most or least effective? What would make the feedback more effective?

Compliment: Thanks for the review, it helped greatly. Your feedback was clear and to the point and it made me realize I could have done a better job.

Suggestion: You stated that some sentence structures needed work on my suggestions. How so? What could I re-written? You did a great job on detailing where it was confusing, but it could be more specific. Ehern004 (talk) 18:41, 21 June 2009 (UTC)